The fair way to compare in-house and outsourced medical billing is cost to collect: the full revenue-cycle cost divided by collections, not biller salaries versus a vendor fee. In-house costs include pay, benefits, software, training, turnover, and supervision. Outsourced billing usually replaces most of that stack with a percentage of collections. AMS Solutions, Inc., a physician-founded medical billing and revenue cycle company founded in 1992, serves practices nationwide and charges a percentage of collections; see the cost page for how AMS prices. Request a Free Billing Analysis to walk through your numbers.
Budget season is when this question gets asked, usually as “what do we pay the billers, and what would a company charge?” That leaves out most of the cost on both sides. Here is how to build a comparison that holds up, whether the budget is for this year or the next one.
Start with the right yardstick: cost to collect
HFMA publishes 29 MAP Keys as the industry benchmarking standard (HFMA MAP Keys, https://www.hfma.org/data-and-insights/map-initiative/map-keys/). Cost to Collect (key FM-6) is total revenue cycle cost divided by total patient service cash collected. HFMA updated that definition in August 2025 (same HFMA MAP Keys page). The costs it says to include are the checklist for this comparison: salaries and fringe benefits, management vendors, subscription fees, outsourced arrangements, purchased services, software and hardware maintenance, bolt-on applications and the staff who support them, IT expense tied to the revenue cycle, record storage, contingency and transaction fees, legal fees, office overhead, and AI or automation workflows.
Two things follow. First, an outsourcing fee is already one of those line items (“outsourced arrangements” and “contingency fees”), so the honest comparison is cost to collect under each model, not salary versus fee. Second, the in-house column is longer than most budgets admit.
The in-house cost stack, line by line
Salaries. The Bureau of Labor Statistics counts medical coders within medical records specialists (SOC 29-2072). May 2025 wage estimates appear in the Occupational Outlook Handbook, last modified 27 August 2026, which also links to state and metro OEWS data (https://www.bls.gov/ooh/healthcare/medical-records-and-health-information-technicians.htm). That is where to pull a wage for your own market. BLS also reports a lower May 2025 median annual wage for this occupation in offices of physicians than in hospitals, state, local, and private, which is why the hospital across town can outbid a small practice for an experienced coder (same OOH Pay section).
Benefits. BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation for June 2026, published 9 September 2026 (USDL-26-1494), puts benefits at 30.0 percent of total compensation cost for private-industry workers, against 70.0 percent for wages ($14.07 and $32.82 of a $46.89 private-industry total). The shorthand of roughly 43 cents of benefits on top of every salary dollar is 14.07 divided by 32.82, and it may be used only with this ECEC citation (https://www.bls.gov/news.release/ecec.nr0.htm). Use your actual benefit cost when you have it.
Software and clearinghouse. Practice management licenses, claim-scrubber subscriptions, clearinghouse transaction fees, eligibility-check fees, statement printing and postage, and the IT support behind them.
Training and code-set maintenance. CMS issued the CY2027 Physician Fee Schedule final rule on 4 November 2026; it was published in the Federal Register on 9 November 2026 and is effective 1 January 2027 (HHS/CMS press release, https://www.hhs.gov/press-room/cms-finalizes-2027-medicare-physician-fee-schedule.html; Federal Register, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/11/09/2026-22743/medicare-and-medicaid-programs-cy-2027-payment-policies-under-the-physician-fee-schedule-and-other). Someone on staff has to learn those changes before the first January claim goes out. This page does not quote payment-impact percentages or conversion factors from that rule. For a longer walk-through of the final rule, see AMS’s 2027 Medicare fee schedule pages.
Turnover and vacancy. BLS projects employment of medical records specialists to grow 8 percent from 2025 to 2035, much faster than the average occupation, with about 14,000 openings a year, many of them replacements (same OOH Job Outlook section). The vacancy itself carries a cost: Medicare claims must be filed within one calendar year of the date of service (42 CFR 424.44, https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-424/subpart-C/section-424.44), and commercial payers set their own deadlines by contract. A vacancy of a few months in a one-biller office puts claims at risk of missing those deadlines.
Management time. Someone supervises the work, reads the remittances, and calls the payer that stopped paying. In a small practice that is often the administrator or the physician.
The outsourced cost stack
An outsourced arrangement is usually priced as a percentage of collections, which converts most of the list above into one variable line. At AMS Solutions, Inc., the fee is a percentage of collections, set out in writing before anything is signed. What that fee covers, and what it does not, is where the comparison gets decided. For how AMS prices, and for how to compare a quote, see How much should medical billing services cost?
Some costs stay in-house under either model: front-desk check-in (collecting the insurance card and copay, and re-verifying coverage at a plan change), charge capture, and the provider’s own documentation and coding sign-off. Eligibility verification itself is part of AMS’s scope when it is contracted for. Budget for the in-house pieces on both sides.
One Medicare rule belongs in this section. Medicare may pay a billing agent directly only if, among other conditions, the agent’s compensation is not related to the dollar amounts billed or collected (42 CFR 424.73(b)(3), https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-424/subpart-E/section-424.73). CMS Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 1, section 30.2.4, states that the conditions in that section do not apply when the agent merely prepares bills and does not receive and negotiate the checks payable to the provider or supplier (https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/Downloads/clm104c01.pdf). So under a percentage-of-collections contract, Medicare payments must go to an account the practice controls, not the vendor’s. The contract should say so.
Side by side
| Cost category | In-house | Outsourced |
|---|---|---|
| Salaries and fringe benefits | Fixed; rises with each hire | Inside the percentage fee |
| Management and supervision | Administrator or physician time | Vendor account management; you still review reports |
| Software, clearinghouse, statements | Separate licenses and transaction fees | Often included; confirm in writing |
| Training on annual code-set and PFS changes | Your staff, your time | Vendor responsibility |
| Turnover and vacancy risk | Yours entirely | Vendor’s, with continuity written into the contract |
| Fee behavior when collections fall | Cost stays flat | Fee falls with collections |
The costs that never hit a line item
Two MAP Keys capture what a cheap billing department can actually cost. Denial write-offs as a percentage of net patient service revenue (HFMA MAP Key AR-6) measures reimbursement written off after denials, whether appeals failed or were never filed (HFMA MAP Keys, https://www.hfma.org/data-and-insights/map-initiative/map-keys/). Aged A/R as a percentage of total billed A/R (HFMA MAP Key AR-1) shows how much of what you have billed is sitting in the older aging buckets, including 91 to 120 days and over 120 days (same HFMA MAP Keys page). A department that looks inexpensive on payroll and expensive on AR-6 and AR-1 is not inexpensive.
Aged A/R and denial write-offs are often where the comparison is won or lost, not on the salary line. For an example of how A/R can move after a billing change, see the internal medicine A/R case study. This page does not quote that case study’s figures.
How to run the comparison
- Pull twelve months of collections, by payer, from the practice management system.
- Build the in-house total using HFMA’s FM-6 list, not just payroll. Include benefits (your actual cost, or the BLS average of about 43 cents per salary dollar, with the ECEC citation above), every software and clearinghouse invoice, and a defensible share of administrator time.
- Get a written outsourcing quote that states the fee basis (gross or net collections), the exclusions, and what happens to A/R that predates the start date.
- Divide each total by collections. That is your cost to collect under each model.
- Adjust for what you are not collecting. Pull AR-1 and AR-6 for the in-house side; ask the vendor how it reports the same keys.
Bring those numbers to a Free Billing Analysis if you want a second set of eyes on the comparison. A billing glossary defining these terms is in the AMS resources library.
When in-house still wins
A large group that can afford a billing manager, certified coders by specialty, and redundancy for every seat has the scale to run a strong internal department. A hospital-owned practice with a central business office already has one. A practice with a long-tenured, well-supervised biller and clean metrics has no reason to change on cost alone.
The practices that often lose on the in-house model are the ones in the middle: enough volume to need more than one biller, not enough to survive losing one. If that describes the practice, run the numbers above, then look at how outsourced medical billing is scoped, and at the longer guide on whether to outsource medical billing. This page is the cost-to-collect comparison, not the service landing page.
Frequently asked questions
How should a practice compare in-house and outsourced medical billing costs?
Compare cost to collect under each model (total revenue-cycle cost divided by collections), not payroll versus a headline fee. Include benefits, software, clearinghouse fees, training, turnover, and supervision on the in-house side.
How does AMS price outsourced billing?
AMS charges a percentage of collections, set out in writing before anything is signed. See https://ams-solutions.com/how-much-should-medical-billing-services-cost/ for how AMS prices.
What costs stay in-house if we outsource?
Front-desk check-in, charge capture, and the provider’s documentation and coding sign-off typically stay with the practice. Confirm eligibility and other scoped tasks in writing.
When does in-house billing still win?
When the practice has the scale for a supervised billing team with backup coverage, or already has a long-tenured team and clean metrics. Cost alone is not a reason to switch in that case.
Do Medicare payments go to the billing company?
Under a percentage-of-collections arrangement, Medicare payments must go to an account the practice controls, not the vendor’s. The contract should say so. Medicare may pay a billing agent directly only if, among other conditions, the agent’s compensation is not related to the dollar amounts billed or collected (42 CFR 424.73(b)(3)); CMS Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 1, section 30.2.4, addresses the case in which the agent prepares bills and does not receive and negotiate the payments.
Will we have to change our EHR to outsource?
No. AMS works inside the practice’s current EHR or practice-management system.
Should I keep medical billing in-house or outsource it?
It depends on the full cost to collect, not on payroll versus a vendor fee, and on whether the in-house team already has coverage, supervision, and clean metrics. In-house can still be the right call. Use the steps on this page, then a Free Billing Analysis, to walk through the numbers.
Request a Free Billing Analysis
If you want help running that comparison on your own numbers, request a Free Billing Analysis. You can start on the Free Billing Analysis page, call 866-973-2221, or request a free consultation as a secondary next step. AMS will walk through the current setup with no pressure to switch, and will say so if staying in-house is the better call.
Weighing a change to how your billing is handled?
Talk it through with us. We will walk through your current setup, what a transition would involve, and what it would cost, with no pressure to switch.
Book a consultationEstimate your current billing cost · More guides for practice owners & managers