There is no single universal rate for medical billing services. Tebra’s 2026 Medical Billing Benchmark Report (https://www.tebra.com/ebook/bp-bc26-the-state-of-the-us-medical-billing-industry) found that more than half of surveyed billing companies (63%) charge 7.99% or less on percentage-based pricing. Tebra’s pricing guidance, “How much should I charge for medical billing services?” (https://www.tebra.com/theintake/practice-operations/billing-companies/how-much-should-i-charge-for-medical-billing-services), also describes a typical quoted range of 4% to 10% of collections, and per-claim fees often quoted from $3 to $10. Flat monthly and hybrid models also exist. The headline percentage is not the real cost, because setup, software, statement, clearinghouse, and old-A/R fees can push an advertised 4% to a higher effective rate (total annual billing cost divided by total annual collections). Compare proposals by effective rate, by what the percentage is calculated on, and by what is included. AMS Solutions generally charges 3%-7% of collections or an agreed monthly minimum, whichever is greater, not both. Request a Free Billing Analysis to see what that would look like for your practice.
The better question is not just “What percentage do you charge?” It is: what will our complete billing operation cost, and what do we receive for that money? One quote may include claim submission, payment posting, denial management, A/R follow-up, patient billing and reporting. Another may charge separately for half of those things.
This article is also a 19-page pricing guide by Brad Becker, CRCR, Regional Billing Manager at AMS Solutions, with the quote-comparison worksheet and the 15-minute billing quote test: https://ams-solutions.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/AMS-How-Much-Should-Medical-Billing-Services-Cost-Brad-Becker-CRCR-v3.pdf
What is a normal medical billing fee?
Pricing varies with specialty, volume, average claim value, payer mix, coding complexity, provider and location count, A/R condition, and scope. Tebra’s pricing guidance, last updated 7 November 2025, describes a typical quoted range of 4% to 10% of collections (https://www.tebra.com/theintake/practice-operations/billing-companies/how-much-should-i-charge-for-medical-billing-services). That range is not a finding of Tebra’s 2026 Medical Billing Benchmark Report. The 2026 report, fielded 1-17 December 2025 among 190 U.S. billing-company respondents, reports this distribution (https://www.tebra.com/ebook/bp-bc26-the-state-of-the-us-medical-billing-industry):
| Percentage charged | Share of billing companies |
|---|---|
| 4.99% or less | 12% |
| 5%-5.99% | 19% |
| 6%-6.99% | 16% |
| 7%-7.99% | 16% |
| 8%-8.99% | 5% |
| 10% or more | 4% |
| Other pricing model | 28% |
In 2025, more than half of billing companies (63%) charge 7.99% or less on percentage-based pricing (Tebra, 2026 Medical Billing Benchmark Report, https://www.tebra.com/ebook/bp-bc26-the-state-of-the-us-medical-billing-industry). The 63% is the 12% + 19% + 16% + 16% in that full-sample table, which also includes a 28% “other pricing model” share. Those numbers provide context. A 4% company and a 7% company may be selling very different versions of revenue-cycle management.
Why billing rates vary from practice to practice
Billing workload does not increase perfectly in proportion to collections. A small practice can require significant infrastructure despite lower revenue, while a larger, clean operation may benefit from scale. Rates also differ by specialty because coding complexity, prior authorization, denial and appeal effort, claim volume, and average claim value change the work per claim. Payer mix can move a quote as well. As context only, not as a medical-billing-industry average or an AMS denial rate, KFF reported that HealthCare.gov insurers denied 19% of in-network claims in 2023, based on CMS data on 425 million claims submitted to 175 ACA marketplace insurers (KFF, 27 January 2025, https://www.kff.org/private-insurance/healthcare-gov-insurers-denied-nearly-1-in-5-in-network-claims-in-2023-but-information-about-reasons-is-limited-in-public-data/). That figure is HealthCare.gov in-network data; it does not include employer plans or state-based marketplaces.
| Practice A | Practice B |
|---|---|
| 15 providers, high monthly collections, straightforward office services, commercial-heavy payer mix, clean existing A/R, efficient EHR workflow | 1 provider, lower monthly collections, complex procedures, difficult payer mix, heavy denial workload, aging A/R and manual follow-up |
Charging both practices the exact same percentage may not make sense. Billing companies should evaluate the actual practice before quoting a rate.
The four common pricing models
| Model | How you pay | Strength | Watch-out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage of collections | An agreed percentage of collected revenue | Scales with reimbursement and aligns the company with collections | The percentage means little until you know the denominator and the scope |
| Per-claim | A fee each time a claim is billed | Predictable unit cost when volume is stable | Ask whether corrected claims, denial resubmissions, and secondary claims each ring the register again |
| Flat monthly | One monthly fee for an agreed scope | Easy to budget | Ask how the price changes when providers, locations, volume, or service requirements increase |
| Hybrid | A percentage or monthly fee plus software, statement, coding, setup, or other charges | Can fit a mixed scope | You must calculate the effective rate before comparing it with a simpler proposal |
Hourly or dedicated-staff arrangements also appear as an uncommon industry variant. They are not an AMS offer.
Under a percentage model, if a practice collects $100,000 in a month and the agreed fee is 5%, the billing fee is $5,000. Get the denominator and the scope in writing. Tebra’s pricing guidance states that many service providers quote per-claim fees ranging from $3 to $10 (https://www.tebra.com/theintake/practice-operations/billing-companies/how-much-should-i-charge-for-medical-billing-services). That range is not a finding of the 2026 benchmark report. If 2,000 claims are billed at $5 each, the monthly cost is $10,000, and it climbs if corrected claims, denial resubmissions, and secondary claims each ring the register again. A flat fee can look cheaper on paper than a percentage of collections; it is not always cheaper in practice, because a flat-fee or per-claim vendor is paid whether or not the claim is collected. Model both at the practice’s actual volume and compare effective rate plus collections performance.
The advertised rate is not always the real rate: calculating your effective billing rate
| Company A | Company B |
|---|---|
| Advertised rate 3.5% plus $500/month software, $300/month account management, statement charges, clearinghouse fees, $1,500 setup, and a separate old-A/R fee | Advertised rate 5%, complete billing scope under the agreed pricing structure |
At first glance Company A looks cheaper. You cannot know until you calculate the total.
Effective billing rate = total annual billing cost divided by total annual collections
| Example | Amount |
|---|---|
| Annual collections | $2,000,000 |
| Quoted billing percentage | 4% |
| Percentage fees | $80,000 |
| Additional annual charges | $25,000 |
| Actual billing cost | $105,000 |
| Effective billing rate | 5.25% |
That “4% billing company” actually costs 5.25% of collections. The 5.25% figure is an illustration of the math, not an AMS result.
Monthly minimums: understand “or” versus “and”
Monthly minimums are not inherently a red flag. They exist because even a low-collection account still requires staffing and follow-up. What matters is how the minimum interacts with the percentage.
| Scenario | Calculation | Billing fee |
|---|---|---|
| Practice collects $100,000 | 5% = $5,000 | $5,000 |
| Practice collects $30,000 | 5% = $1,500 | $2,500 minimum |
In this example the agreed minimum is $2,500. The practice does not pay 5% plus $2,500; the minimum applies only when the percentage falls below the floor. At a 5% rate with a $2,500 minimum, percentage pricing exceeds the minimum once monthly collections reach $50,000. A “5% or $2,500, whichever is greater” model and a “5% plus $2,500 every month” model are different economics. Confirm which one is in the contract.
Smaller practices are often quoted a percentage of collections with a monthly minimum as a floor. Some vendors quote a flat monthly or per-claim fee instead. Compare the effective first-year cost and the scope, and ask about the minimum in writing.
What the percentage is calculated on (collections, charges, or gross revenue)
A percentage of net collections is not a percentage of gross charges, and it is not a percentage of the practice’s gross revenue. Those denominators produce very different fees for the same headline rate. Get the definition in writing. Ask whether front-desk copays, deductibles, patient collections, historical A/R, or only claims the company worked are in the denominator. AMA guidance has long advised practices to clarify whether a billing company charges only on collections it directly assisted with, or on broader practice collections including copays and deductibles (AMA Electronic Funds Transfer Toolkit, https://www.ama-assn.org/media/11081/download).
Usually included versus usually extra
A full-service base fee typically covers claim scrubbing and submission, payment posting, denial follow-up, and standard monthly reporting. Other items are frequently billed separately, and you should always ask: implementation and setup; patient statements and postage; patient phone support; old A/R cleanup; credentialing and payer enrollment; custom reporting; software or clearinghouse pass-throughs; EHR interface fees; and data-export or early-termination charges.
Tebra’s 2026 Medical Billing Benchmark Report found that the share of surveyed billing companies that never charge setup fees dropped from 36% in 2023 to 19% in 2025, and that 39% always or often charge setup fees in 2025; 98% now offer add-on services beyond core claims processing, up from 80% in 2023 (https://www.tebra.com/ebook/bp-bc26-the-state-of-the-us-medical-billing-industry). A service being “available” does not mean it is included in the quoted rate. Get every fee into the agreement.
As industry context only, not as an AMS result or a practice-level savings promise, the 2024 CAQH Index (published February 2025) estimated an $18.4 billion remaining savings opportunity for the medical industry from moving remaining manual and partial administrative transactions to fully electronic ones (https://www.caqh.org/hubfs/Index/2024%20Index%20Report/CAQH_IndexReport_2024_FINAL.pdf).
What 3% to 7% actually looks like in dollars
Simple illustrations of the fee at different collection levels, before any monthly minimum:
| Rate | $100,000/month collections | $250,000/month collections |
|---|---|---|
| 3% | $3,000/month, $36,000/year | $7,500/month, $90,000/year |
| 4% | $4,000/month, $48,000/year | $10,000/month, $120,000/year |
| 5% | $5,000/month, $60,000/year | $12,500/month, $150,000/year |
| 6% | $6,000/month, $72,000/year | $15,000/month, $180,000/year |
| 7% | $7,000/month, $84,000/year | $17,500/month, $210,000/year |
Those numbers can look significant. Revenue-cycle management is a major operational function. This table is fee education on this page, not a statement that AMS always charges a single point inside the range.
Price does not exist in a vacuum
| Company A | Company B | |
|---|---|---|
| Billing rate | 4% | 5% |
| Annual collections | $2,000,000 | $2,100,000 |
| Annual billing fee | $80,000 | $105,000 |
| Net after billing fee | $1,920,000 | $1,995,000 |
Company B costs $25,000 more and leaves the practice $75,000 ahead in this illustration. The cheapest billing company is not automatically the least expensive one. On $1 million in collections, a one-point pricing difference equals $10,000 per year. Evaluate the fee, then evaluate what the fee buys. For a full in-house versus outsourced cost-to-collect comparison, see In-House vs. Outsourced Medical Billing (https://ams-solutions.com/in-house-vs-outsourced-medical-billing/).
Ask who owns the hard money
Almost anyone can collect the easy money: a clean claim goes out, the payer processes it, payment arrives. The difference appears when reimbursement does not follow the happy path. Who works the denial, the rejection, the recoupment, the underpayment, the 120-day A/R, and the payer escalation? The expensive part of billing is rarely clicking submit. And ask who employs those people: see Who is actually doing your medical billing? (https://ams-solutions.com/who-is-actually-doing-your-medical-billing/).
What are you actually paying a billing company to do?
A full-service company should do more than push claims through a clearinghouse: charge review, claim submission and edits, rejection management, payment posting, denial management, appeals, A/R follow-up, patient billing, payer escalation, secondary claims, revenue-cycle analysis, account management, and reporting. Reporting should include collections, charges, days in A/R, aging including A/R over 90 and 120 days, denial and rejection trends, adjustments, write-offs, payer performance, and patient balances. A claim-submission-only service and a full revenue-cycle operation should not be compared solely by percentage.
Five questions to ask every billing company, and a short list that exposes hidden fees
Use the same questions with every company.
- What is our total expected cost, including every mandatory fee, minimum, and recurring charge?
- What is included? Get the complete scope in writing.
- What costs extra? If the answer is nothing, confirm that in the agreement.
- How do you handle denials, A/R, appeals, rejections, and payer follow-up?
- How will we know whether you are doing a good job?
Add these when you are testing for hidden fees or a thin contract:
- What is the percentage calculated on, and are copays, deductibles, patient collections, historical A/R, or only claims the company worked in the denominator?
- Do corrected claims, denial resubmissions, and secondary claims each create a new fee?
- What are the setup, software, statement, clearinghouse, old-A/R, termination, and data-export charges?
- Who owns the denial work, the aged A/R, and the reporting, and is that work in the base fee?
- How does the agreement end, and what does it cost to leave and export the data?
Have ready for a quote: specialty, provider count, approximate monthly collections, current billing structure, basic A/R, and the EHR in use. The downloadable guide includes a quote-comparison worksheet and a 15-minute billing quote test. For a broader buyer checklist, see How to Choose a Medical Billing Company (https://ams-solutions.com/how-to-choose-a-medical-billing-company/). Get the pricing model, denominator, every fee, the scope, reporting, and how the agreement ends in writing before signing.
Pricing red flags
| What you hear | What to ask |
|---|---|
| “Our rate is only 3%.” | Great. What else do we pay? |
| “Denial management is available.” | Included or additional? Weak denial follow-up is a cost, even when the headline rate looks low. |
| “We can work old A/R.” | At what rate? |
| “Statements are handled through our platform.” | Who pays for them? |
| “We provide reporting.” | Which reports, and how often? No reporting transparency makes the fee impossible to judge. |
| “There is a small monthly technology charge.” | How small? Multiply it by twelve. |
| “We can discuss pricing after implementation.” | Understand pricing before signing. |
| “That integration is included.” | Are there transaction, setup, or third-party fees? |
| “Leaving is simple.” | What are the termination and data-export charges? Steep exit penalties can trap a practice in a cheap-looking contract. |
And do not negotiate yourself into a worse service. If a company drops from 6% to 3.5%, ask what changed in staffing, A/R follow-up, coding, account management, or scope. Sometimes the product being purchased is now different.
How this page relates to AMS billing services and A/R benchmarks
This page is the cost-and-quote-comparison guide. The main billing service page remains at https://ams-solutions.com/services/billing/. The A/R-over-90 guide remains at https://ams-solutions.com/ar-over-90-days-what-is-too-much/. Those URLs stay distinct; this page does not copy their service copy or their page-scoped A/R figures. Related reading: outsourcing inclusions and the 90-day transition (https://ams-solutions.com/outsourced-medical-billing/), small and independent practices (https://ams-solutions.com/medical-billing-services-small-practices/), old A/R recovery (https://ams-solutions.com/services/collections/), and revenue-cycle management (https://ams-solutions.com/services/revenue-cycle-management/).
How AMS Solutions prices medical billing
AMS Solutions generally charges 3%-7% of collections or an agreed monthly minimum, whichever is greater. The exact percentage and minimum depend on the practice, specialty, volume and operational complexity, and the minimum is a floor, not an additional fee stacked on top of the percentage. The philosophy is deliberately simple: the billing fee is the percentage or the minimum, not the percentage plus a pile of miscellaneous billing charges. We do not want a practice manager reconciling a quoted collection percentage against a stack of small surcharges, and the simplicity makes the performance conversation cleaner: instead of asking whether a particular denial fell inside a premium package, the practice can ask the question that matters: how is our revenue cycle performing?
So how much should medical billing cost?
A practice paying 4% for poor billing is paying too much, and a practice paying 6% for a revenue cycle that consistently performs may be receiving excellent value. Compare proposals by effective rate, by what the percentage is calculated on, and by what is included. Then decide whether the service justifies the cost.
Want to know what your practice would actually pay? Send your specialty, provider count, approximate monthly collections, current billing structure, and basic A/R, and we will return a proposal with one billing structure and one clearly defined scope. Request a Free Billing Analysis at https://ams-solutions.com/free-medical-billing-audit/ or call 866-973-2221. AMS Solutions, Inc., physician-founded in 1992, serves practices nationwide, in all 50 states, with billing, credentialing, and old A/R recovery under one roof.
Frequently asked questions
How much do medical billing companies charge?
Tebra’s pricing guidance describes a typical quoted range of 4% to 10% of collections, and per-claim fees often quoted from $3 to $10 (https://www.tebra.com/theintake/practice-operations/billing-companies/how-much-should-i-charge-for-medical-billing-services). Tebra’s 2026 Medical Billing Benchmark Report found that more than half of surveyed billing companies (63%) charge 7.99% or less on percentage-based pricing (https://www.tebra.com/ebook/bp-bc26-the-state-of-the-us-medical-billing-industry). Flat monthly fees and hybrid models also exist. The right comparison is the effective rate, total annual cost divided by annual collections, and the scope included.
What is a good percentage for medical billing?
It depends on scope, specialty, volume, and A/R condition. A lower rate for claim submission only can cost more than a higher full-service rate that includes denials, A/R follow-up, posting, and reporting, once software, statement, and old-A/R fees are added. Calculate the effective rate before judging the percentage.
What is an effective billing rate?
Total annual billing cost (percentage fees plus every software, statement, clearinghouse, setup, and other charge) divided by total annual collections. A quoted 4% with $25,000 of additional annual charges on $2 million in collections is an effective rate of 5.25%. That illustration is math, not an AMS result.
Are monthly minimums normal in medical billing contracts?
Yes. A minimum covers the fixed work a low-volume account still requires. The key is whether it is “percentage or minimum, whichever is greater” (a floor) or “percentage plus minimum” (an added fee every month). Get the structure in writing.
Does the percentage apply to copays and patient payments?
Only if the contract says so. Ask whether the percentage applies to insurance collections, patient collections, copays collected at the front desk, deductibles, historical A/R, or only claims the company worked, and have the denominator written into the agreement; AMA guidance has long advised practices to clarify this (AMA Electronic Funds Transfer Toolkit, https://www.ama-assn.org/media/11081/download).
How much does AMS Solutions charge?
Generally 3%-7% of collections or an agreed monthly minimum, whichever is greater, not both. The exact rate and minimum depend on the practice, specialty, volume and complexity, and the quoted structure covers the full billing scope without separate billing add-ons.
Is a flat fee cheaper than a percentage of collections?
Sometimes on paper, not always in practice. A flat-fee or per-claim vendor is paid whether or not the claim is collected, so weak follow-up can cost more than the fee savings. Model both at the practice’s actual volume and compare effective rate plus collections performance.
How do billing companies charge for small practices?
Often a percentage of collections with a monthly minimum as a floor, because a low-volume account still requires staffing and follow-up. Some vendors quote a flat monthly or per-claim fee instead. Compare the effective first-year cost and the scope, and ask about the minimum in writing.
What should be included in a medical billing contract?
The pricing model and denominator; every fee (setup, minimum, software, statements, old A/R, termination or data export); the scope of services; reporting; and how the agreement ends. Get it in writing before signing.
Why do rates differ by specialty?
Coding complexity, prior authorization, denial and appeal effort, claim volume, and average claim value change the work per claim. Ask the company to explain the quote against that workload, rather than treating a headline percentage as a specialty-wide rate.
Is outsourced medical billing cheaper than in-house?
It can be, once salaries, benefits, software, training, and turnover are counted, but the honest comparison is cost to collect plus net collections, not salary versus a vendor fee. See In-House vs. Outsourced Medical Billing (https://ams-solutions.com/in-house-vs-outsourced-medical-billing/) for that decision.
Request a Free Billing Analysis at https://ams-solutions.com/free-medical-billing-audit/ or call 866-973-2221.
Prepared by Brad Becker, CRCR, Regional Billing Manager, AMS Solutions. Sources: Tebra, 2026 Medical Billing Benchmark Report; Tebra, “How much should I charge for medical billing services?”; AMA Electronic Funds Transfer Toolkit; KFF, HealthCare.gov in-network claim denials in 2023 (27 January 2025); 2024 CAQH Index (published February 2025). Industry pricing is not standardized; examples are illustrations, not guarantees of financial performance.