Reviewed November 17, 2026
Run this scorecard before year-end, so anything it flags can be raised with your billing company before the new year starts.
Your billing company is doing a good job if it sends the same report every month without being asked, your A/R over 90 days is holding steady or shrinking, denials come with reasons and a fix, and problems reach you from billing before they reach you from patients. If you cannot tell whether those things are true, that is the first thing to fix.
Our guide to the 5 billing KPIs to review monthly explains what each number means. This page is about using them to hold your billing company, or your in-house team, accountable.
Ground rules before the numbers
- Get the same report every month, unprompted. If you have to ask for reports, or they arrive in a different format each time, start there.
- Compare against your own trend. Benchmarks vary by specialty, payer mix and how a metric is calculated. The most reliable test is whether your numbers are improving, holding or slipping month over month.
- Ask how each number is calculated, and keep the definition the same every month. Two companies can report “collection rate” in ways that are not comparable.
You can send this request as written:
“Starting next month, please send by the 10th: days in A/R, A/R over 90 days, net collection rate, clean claim rate, denial rate with the top five reasons, charge lag, unworked denials, credit balances and patient A/R, each compared with the prior three months. Please also set up read-only access to our practice management system for me.”
The scorecard
| Metric | Formula | What should make you ask questions |
|---|---|---|
| Days in A/R | Total A/R ÷ average daily charges (e.g., last 90 days of gross charges ÷ 90; use the same window every month) | Rising over several months |
| A/R over 90 days | A/R older than 90 days ÷ total A/R | A growing share |
| Net collection rate | Payments ÷ (charges − contractual adjustments), same period | Falling |
| Clean claim rate | Claims accepted on first submission without rejection ÷ claims submitted | Falling |
| Denial rate | Initial denials ÷ claims submitted (count each claim’s first denial once), with top reasons | Reported without reasons |
| Charge lag | Average days from date of service to claim submission | Growing |
| Unworked denials | Denials with no appeal, correction or write-off decision after 30 days | Anything more than a handful |
| Credit balances | Overpayments not yet refunded or resolved | Growing |
| Patient A/R | Patient balances by age | Growing older |
Our detailed guides explain each metric: days in A/R, clean claim rate, net vs gross collection rate, and which revenue cycle metrics matter (and which to ignore).
A note on credit balances: unresolved overpayments are not just a bookkeeping issue. Medicare requires identified overpayments to be reported and returned within 60 days, and other payers have their own rules.
What billing controls, and what it does not
Before you blame your billing company for a bad month, separate its numbers from yours:
- Charge lag often starts with how quickly providers sign their notes.
- Eligibility denials usually start at check-in, when insurance is not verified.
- Coding denials can start in the documentation.
Your billing company owns follow-up, appeals, payment posting, unworked denials and the clarity of its reporting. A good partner will tell you which side each problem sits on. A weak one blames the practice for everything, or never mentions the practice at all.
Questions that reveal more than the numbers
Numbers tell you what happened. These questions tell you whether anyone is managing it:
- “What were our top five denial reasons last month, and what is being done about each?” A good answer names a root cause and a fix, not just “we appealed them.”
- “How do you know if a payer underpaid us?” Your billing team should compare payments against your contracted rates, not just accept what arrives.
- “What happens to a denial after it comes in?” Listen for a defined process and a timeframe.
- “Which payer is slowest to pay us right now, and why?”
- “How much did we write off last month, and for what reasons?” Write-offs should be categorized, explained and approved.
- “Who do I call when I have a question, and how fast will I hear back?”
Red flags
Any one of these is worth a conversation. Several together usually mean billing is underperforming:
- Reports show only collections, with nothing (charges or allowed amounts) to compare them against.
- The share of A/R over 90 days keeps growing.
- Denials are reported as a total, without reasons.
- Large adjustments or write-offs with no explanation.
- You hear about problems from patients or payers before your billing team tells you.
- The answer to most questions is “we are looking into it,” month after month.
What to do with the results
If the scorecard looks healthy, keep running it monthly. Once the reports arrive in a consistent format, it takes a few minutes and it is the best early warning you have.
If several numbers are moving the wrong way, share the scorecard with your billing company or team and ask for a written plan with dates. A reasonable rule: if two or more red flags are still there three months after you asked for that plan, start comparing alternatives. Our guide on how to switch billing companies without stranding claims walks through doing that safely.
Not sure your reports show the whole picture?
An outside review of the same numbers is the quickest way to find out. Bring last month’s reports to the free A/R analysis below.
Want these numbers for your own practice?
Send us a few standard reports and we will review your A/R, denials and collection rate, then send back written findings: what is working, where revenue is slipping, and what to fix first. Free, no contract, and useful whether or not you work with us.
Request a free A/R analysis