How to Know if Your Medical Billing Company Is Doing a Good Job

By Brad Becker, CRCR, Regional Billing Manager at AMS Solutions. 7-page printable PDF, free.

If you outsource your billing, there is a deceptively simple question you should be able to answer: is your billing company actually doing a good job? Money is coming in, claims are going out, reports arrive every month. But are you collecting what you should? Are denials being resolved? Is old A/R really being worked? You do not need to become a billing expert to answer that. You need to know which numbers to look at, what questions to ask and what good revenue-cycle management should feel like from the practice side.

What’s inside

Who it’s for

Practice owners and administrators who outsource billing today and want an objective read on whether the partner is performing.

Get the guide

Enter your details and the PDF opens immediately. We’ll also keep you posted with a few short, practical notes on the same topic; you can unsubscribe at any time.


Read the guide online

Start with the numbers

Revenue-cycle performance should never be a black box. Six indicators say a great deal: clean claim rate (how often claims pass initial billing without manual correction; watch for frequent rejections and preventable rework), denial rate (how often payers deny; watch for rising volume or repeat categories), days in A/R (how long revenue stays outstanding; watch for a rising trend), A/R over 90 days (how much receivable is becoming old; watch for growth without a recovery plan), net collection rate (how much collectible revenue is actually collected; watch for underpayments, preventable write-offs and missed follow-up) and charge or claim lag (how quickly services become claims; watch for encounters sitting unbilled). HFMA includes clean claim rate, aged A/R, remittance denial rate and net days in A/R among its standardized MAP Keys. For context, across AMS Solutions’ active client book the 2026 benchmark snapshot is a 95%+ clean claim rate, denials under 5%, 30 to 40 days in A/R, under 10% of A/R over 90 days, a 96% net collection rate and 90%+ first-pass resolution; specialty, payer mix and operations all affect performance, so treat benchmarks as context rather than guarantees.

The exact number matters; the trend matters even more. A practice at 38 days in A/R that improved from 52 is moving the right way. A practice at 38 that was at 27 six months ago deserves a conversation. Your billing company should be able to explain both.

Your billing company should know where your money is

Ask a simple question: what is currently preventing us from getting paid? A good partner has an answer. A payer is processing slowly, authorization denials are rising for a procedure, one provider’s documentation is delaying coding, an enrollment issue is holding claims, or a significant balance is sitting in patient responsibility. A monthly report that shows charges, payments and A/R is only the beginning. Good reporting explains why the numbers look the way they do and what is being done about it.

Claims and denials

A claim cannot get paid if it never successfully enters adjudication. CMS defines a clean claim as one that does not require external investigation or development before processing. Incorrect demographics, invalid insurance information, missing modifiers, credentialing problems, authorization issues and formatting errors all create friction. Some problems will always happen; what matters is whether preventable errors are identified and reduced. If your billing company keeps correcting the same type of rejection without addressing why it keeps happening, the problem is being worked but not solved.

Denials should be managed, not merely resubmitted. Working denials means fixing individual claims; managing denials means identifying patterns so fewer claims are denied in the first place. If the practice keeps receiving authorization denials for the same service, someone should ask why the authorization workflow keeps failing. The strongest billing operations close the loop between the back end and the front end.

A/R and reporting

A healthy-looking total A/R can hide a lot. Two practices with $400,000 in receivables are not equally healthy if one balance is mostly recent and the other has a large share sitting past 90 or 120 days. “We’re working it” is not an A/R strategy; you should understand which categories of money are outstanding, why, and what actions are being taken. Look at what you collect, not just what you charge: if collections rose 8% while charges rose 20%, that tells a different story. Net collection performance, what you collect of what you were entitled to after legitimate contractual adjustments, is the figure that matters.

Useful reporting should help leadership understand what was billed and collected, what remains outstanding and how it is aging, what is being denied, rejected or held, which payers or workflows are creating problems, and what the billing team is doing next and needs from the practice. Reporting should create visibility; account management should create understanding.

Communication and accountability

You should not need to chase your billing company to find out what is happening with your own money. Questions get answers, problems have owners and significant payer issues are communicated proactively. A good partner also tells you things you do not want to hear: your documentation does not support that code, your staff is not obtaining the authorization, a provider is closing charts too slowly, the front desk is entering insurance incorrectly, this balance should not simply be adjusted off. A billing company that agrees with everything the practice says is not necessarily doing it any favors.

Be careful with “our collection rate is 99%.” Metrics are only useful when everyone agrees on how they are calculated. HFMA developed its MAP Keys specifically to promote consistent definitions. If a vendor reports a 99% collection rate, ask how it is calculated; if it reports a 2% denial rate, ask what counts as a denial; if days in A/R look extremely low, ask whether old balances or certain categories are excluded.

Warning signs

You cannot easily obtain basic A/R, collections or denial reports. Your billing company cannot tell you your days in A/R or how much is older than 90 days. Old balances keep growing without explanation. You repeatedly discover unworked claims or denials yourself. The same denial categories recur month after month without a corrective plan. Claims or encounters regularly sit unsubmitted. Significant payer or credentialing issues reach you only after revenue is affected. Your account manager cannot explain changes in collections. Reports arrive, but nobody reviews them with you. Write-offs occur without visibility into why. One bad month does not mean you need a new billing company; patterns are different.

The simplest test

At your next billing meeting ask: What are our current days in A/R? What percentage of our A/R is over 90 days? What are our top five denial categories right now? What is currently preventing us from collecting money faster? What are you doing about each of those problems? The answer to “is my billing company doing a good job” should ultimately be measurable, and you should not have to take anyone’s word for it. The data should tell the story.


Prefer the printable version with the worksheets and checklists? Use the form above. And if you would like a second set of eyes on your own numbers, AMS Solutions offers a no-obligation review of your A/R and recent billing performance: call 866-973-2221 or email info@ams-solutions.com.

This guide is for general operational and educational purposes. Payer rules, contracts, timely-filing limits and practice circumstances vary; results are not guaranteed.

Free Consultation

Schedule Meeting