Medicare Advantage eligibility verification in January means re-checking every Medicare patient, not only new ones. Medicare’s Open Enrollment Period runs 15 October to 7 December, and those changes take effect 1 January. The most common January miss is billing last year’s plan after the patient switched Medicare Advantage plans or returned to Original Medicare.

The card in your system was accurate in December. For some of your Medicare patients it stops being accurate on New Year’s Day, and nothing about the visit tells the front desk. Often the first sign is a remittance weeks later. This post covers what changes, why those claims deny, and what to re-verify before the first January appointment.

The patient-balance side of January, meaning deductible resets, estimates and point-of-service collection scripts, is covered in our Q4 deductible season playbook. This post covers the payer side.

Two enrollment windows, two effective dates

Medicare.gov’s “Joining a plan” page sets out the windows that matter to a practice:

  • Open Enrollment Period, 15 October to 7 December. A beneficiary can join, drop or switch a Medicare Advantage plan, move from Original Medicare to Medicare Advantage or back, and change drug coverage. Coverage starts 1 January of the next year, as long as the plan gets the request by 7 December.
  • Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period, 1 January to 31 March. Only for people already in a Medicare Advantage plan. They can switch to another Medicare Advantage plan or drop Medicare Advantage and return to Original Medicare. Coverage starts the first of the month after the plan gets the request.

The second window is the one practices forget. A patient verified clean on 5 January can be on a different plan on 1 February, 1 March or 1 April. Special Enrollment Periods, which Medicare.gov ties to events such as moving or gaining Medicaid, can change coverage in any month. January is the heaviest re-verification month, but it isn’t the only one.

Why January Medicare claims deny

The claim went to the wrong payer. CMS’s HETS companion guide (May 2026) tells providers that eligibility, coverage and payment questions for a Medicare Advantage enrollee go to the MA plan named in the eligibility response, and that you must follow that plan’s terms for payment. Bill the Medicare Administrative Contractor for a patient who moved into Medicare Advantage, or bill last year’s MA plan for a patient who went back to Original Medicare, and the claim comes back. On the remittance, X12’s code list gives the likely reasons: CARC 24 (charges covered under a capitation agreement or managed care plan), CARC 27 (expenses incurred after coverage terminated) and CARC 109 (not covered by this payer; send to the correct payer).

The member ID and network changed. A new plan means a new member ID and often a new network. Being in network with a patient’s 2026 plan says nothing about their 2027 plan, even when both come from the same carrier.

PCP assignment and referral rules reset. Medicare.gov’s page on HMO plans says that in most HMOs the member needs to choose a primary care doctor and, in most cases, needs a referral to see a specialist. A patient who changed plans may have no PCP on file yet, or may have been assigned one who isn’t you. Referral requirements are plan-specific, so confirm them on the new plan’s portal.

Prior authorizations don’t simply carry over. A course of treatment approved by last year’s plan is not an authorization from this year’s plan. There is a federal backstop: under 42 CFR 422.112(b)(8), Medicare Advantage coordinated care plans must give a new enrollee who is mid-way through an active course of treatment a minimum 90-day transition period, without disrupting the treatment or requiring reauthorization. Use those 90 days to get the new plan’s authorization on file. Don’t treat them as a reason to skip it.

The deductible reset. CMS set the 2026 Part B deductible at $283 (fact sheet, 14 November 2025). Update your estimates when CMS publishes the 2027 figure. For Medicare Advantage patients the plan sets cost sharing, and the HETS guide notes that each MA plan can have different out-of-pocket costs. Last year’s copay isn’t a safe estimate.

How to verify: HETS first, then the plan

For Original Medicare status, CMS’s HIPAA Eligibility Transaction System (HETS) returns real-time 271 responses to 270 eligibility requests. CMS notes that HETS handles real-time transactions only, not batch files, so your practice management system or clearinghouse has to be set up for it. The companion guide describes what the 271 gives you about Medicare Advantage:

  • Every MA plan whose enrollment period overlaps the date of service you asked about, with a plan type (HMO, PPO, point of service or indemnity).
  • An “MA Bill Option Code” showing whether the MA plan or Medicare’s contractor processes the claims.

For Original Medicare patients, the 271 also returns the Part B deductible and coinsurance for each calendar year in the dates you ask about (section 7.7). It won’t return a future year’s deductible or coinsurance until CMS has published them (section 7.2), which is another reason to run the check close to the visit.

HETS tells you which plan. It does not tell you that plan’s PCP assignment, referral rules or authorization list. For that, go to the MA plan’s own portal or run a 270 to the plan directly.

Run the check against the actual date of service. A January check run for a December date will show you the old plan.

The January re-verification checklist

  1. Re-run eligibility for every Medicare patient scheduled in January, dated to the appointment, not the scheduling date.
  2. Compare the 271 to what’s on file: payer, plan type, member ID and MA Bill Option Code. Any difference flags the account before check-in.
  3. Scan the new card at the first 2027 visit, front and back, even when the patient says “nothing changed.”
  4. Confirm network status for the new plan before the visit, not after the denial.
  5. Check PCP assignment and referral requirements on the plan portal, and get the referral on file first.
  6. Re-establish prior authorizations with the new plan. Note the 90-day transition end date for patients in an active course of treatment.
  7. Update the cost-share estimate with 2027 figures: Part B deductible for Original Medicare, plan-specific copays and deductibles for Medicare Advantage.
  8. Flag the account for a re-check on 1 February, 1 March and 1 April, the dates Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment changes can take effect.
  9. Hold, don’t guess. If eligibility is unclear at check-in, route the claim to a work queue instead of submitting to last year’s payer.

When the change is retroactive

Sometimes the plan finds out after you do. A patient is disenrolled from a Medicare Advantage plan retroactively, the plan takes back its payment, and the Medicare filing window has closed by then. Medicare’s timely-filing regulation covers this. Under 42 CFR 424.44(b)(4), CMS extends the deadline when the patient was in an MA plan at the time of service, was later disenrolled retroactively, and the plan recovered its payment six months or more after the service. The extension runs through the last day of the sixth calendar month after the month of the recovery (§424.44(b)(5)(iv)). Keep the plan’s recoupment notice, because it starts that clock.

For more on reading the codes these denials arrive with, see our guide to CARC and RARC codes. Front-desk checklists and billing quick-references are in the AMS resources library.

If January eligibility clean-up keeps landing on your billing team after the denials arrive, eligibility verification is part of AMS’s revenue cycle management services when it is contracted for, with your front desk still collecting the card and copay at check-in. AMS has worked on practice revenue cycles since 1992.

About the Author

AMS Solutions is a full-service medical billing and revenue cycle management company serving physicians and healthcare practices nationwide since 1992. Our team writes about medical billing, claim denial prevention, coding updates, and practice revenue, helping providers get paid accurately and efficiently so they can focus on patient care.

Share This Blog
Free Consultation

Get Straight Forward Pricing

We work every angle to minimize denials, increase cash flow, reduce A/R, and maximize your profitability. Find out how we can help your practice.

Recent Posts

Free Consultation

Schedule Meeting